Incorporating Home Performance into HVAC
October 31, 2012
A version of this article appears in the November/December 2012 issue of Home Energy Magazine.
On one hand, it would seem that for the HVAC contractor, incorporating home performance into his offering would be a natural progression. On the other hand, there are many obstacles to doing so, not least of which is skepticism on the part of many HVAC and home performance contractors. Yet in the long run, there is good reason to believe that for the HVAC contractor, incorporating home performance into his offering is inevitable.
One HVAC contractor who has done so successfully is Jeff Gill, president of Indoor Airman Home Performance in Grants Pass, Oregon. When Gill became an HVAC contractor about four years ago, he immediately saw that he needed to include home performance. But that came from his 20 previous years of being an exterminator. “We’d go into a home and find the ductwork all chewed up by rats,” he says.
That puts Gill in a good position to answer one of the common questions raised by skeptical HVAC contractors: Why would an HVAC contractor want to go back into the customer’s home and test the leakiness of the ducts he’d installed? Won’t that make the HVAC contractor look bad?”
Gill’s answer is that if the HVAC contractor doesn’t provide this maintenance and the ducts leak, he already looks bad. “Many of these contractors just don’t care,” Gill says. “They never check the duct lines.”
This leads to another common complaint that Gill often gets asked. Why should an HVAC contractor take on insulation and air sealing if he’s making enough money now simply swapping mechanical boxes?
“Just swapping boxes is doing the customer a disservice,” says Gill. “It’s not a question of simple mechanics. If you put in an expensive heater and the house isn’t properly sealed, all you're doing is heating up the outdoors.”
Gill’s approach, on the other hand, “is to look at the house holistically, not just installing a new heating system or the duct-work, but considering everything from the attic to the understructure.” Much of it, Gill says, is common sense, including window and door sealing, weather-stripping, installing insulation, cleaning the coil and blower wheel, and so on.
Although the areas of the home that should be checked seem clear, when asked if actually implementing a totally energy efficient home envelope might be a bit complicated, Gill-replies, “Oh, yes, it is complicated! You need special training to really learn how to do home performance.” Gill received training and earned his Building Analyst certification from the Building Performance Institute, Inc. (BPI).
Is It Worth It to Learn This New Discipline?
“Once you get it down, it really works for you,” Gill says. “When we show the owner how simple sealing and maintenance measures create a safer and healthier home—such as by cleaning a moldy understructure and increasing IAQ—and how they can reduce energy bills by 20–30%, we don’t even have to sell a piece of HVAC equipment. We look at homeowners as lifelong customers. If you’re honest with them, and show them what they need, one step at a time, it’s amazing how much they appreciate you. When it comes down to buying a piece of equipment, they’ll come right to you, for they trust you that you’ll sell them what they need and not oversell just to pocket more of their money. This really brings HVAC up to a new level.”
Gill reports that in the four years since he left the exterminator business, which he and his son ran by themselves, he’s grown to 20 employees. He also says that if an HVAC contractor feels he can’t afford the training and time it takes to become a qualified home performance contractor, he should subcontract this work. For Gill, however, the cost and effort have been well worth it. “We now have a statewide plan we’re going to take national,” he says.
The Bellingham, Washington-based Comfort Institute, which works in cooperation with BPI, is aimed at moving HVAC contractors into home performance. The institute’s founder and CEO, Brendan Reid, started (and for many years ran) Retrotec, a blower door manufacturer. But he felt the need to help push the industry toward home performance, so in 1997, he founded the institute. Ken Summers, who also worked at Retrotec, felt the same need, so he joined Reid in the new venture as vice president.
Summers says that, working with BPI, the institute offers business training and leadership programs, as well as sales and marketing skills designed to help HVAC contractors make the transition.
“Our biggest challenge as the industry changes is that too many people don’t like change,” Summers says. “The issue here is that too many HVAC contractors say, ‘I’m fine, I’ve got my business, I’m satisfied, I don’t need to change. It takes a lot of work to change this attitude.’”
On the plus side, Summers says there is now a more concerted push from both EPA and from various state programs. He adds that the institute provides training for Carrier dealers on home performance business implementation, building science, and sales leads.
Carrier Corporation Leading the Merge
Carrier Corporation, based in Indianapolis, Indiana, is championing the incorporation of home performance into HVAC. This is significant, since Carrier is the world’s leader in high-tech heating, air-conditioning, and refrigeration solutions. Carrier announced its new Energy Experts program on March 27, 2012. It is the first major manufacturer to offer such a program, but others are expected to follow its lead.
Carrier Energy Experts will conduct home performance audits that analyze such factors as the heating-and-cooling system, airflow, and the home envelope, and provide solutions to improve the overall efficiency of the home.
“According to DOE’s Buildings Energy Data Book, heating and cooling accounts for about 54% of a typical home’s energy usage,” says Carrier Brand Manager Matt Nuijens. “Our dealers are already HVAC experts, so the Energy Experts program is a natural next step.”
Nuijens explains that the Energy Experts audit consists of a six-step assessment of HVAC, air filtration and distribution, and the home envelope. The six steps are inspection, testing, analysis, recommendations, resolution, and results. Auditors use thermal-imaging cameras, blower door testing equipment, static-pressure gauges, and other state-of-the-art technology. Following the audit, homeowners are told how they can improve home performance by making adjustments to their home energy systems. These adjustments include repairing, upgrading, or replacing their heating-and-cooling and air filtration and distribution systems, as well as tightening the home envelope.
“The fact that Carrier, the world’s largest HVAC manufacturer, is the first out of the gate is very exciting, and I’m sure this example will translate to other manufacturers within the next 12 months. After all, Carrier is motivated not by altruism but by profitability,” says Mike Rogers, vice president of ABM Energy, in Burlington, Vermont.
When we show the owner how simple sealing and maintenance measures create a safer and healthier home, we don’t even have to sell a piece of HVAC equipment.
ABM is also a giant, a Fortune 500 facility management company with a wide range of industrial, commercial, and residential clients, through its GreenHomes America division. Rogers says GreenHomes America is similar in outlook to Carrier in that it’s not a small, idealistic, grassroots nonprofit group out to save the environment, but a very pragmatic business out to deliver customer satisfaction and grow a profitable operation.
“The business case for home performance boils down to increasing revenues, margins, and the bottom line,” says Rogers. “How you do it is straightforward. The details can get complicated, but the premise is very simple: You make the whole house more comfortable and energy efficient.”
Though Rogers acknowledges that much more remains to be done, he maintains that for about the past six years the whole-house approach has grown from theory to reality. Rogers is in a good position to know, for over a decade ago he worked at and with various federal agencies, including EPA and DOE. In fact, Rogers was one of the originators of the Home Performance with Energy Star program. “In those early years we had the joke that there were five guys around the country actually implementing home performance,” Rogers recalls. “Now I think there are about 26 states that are really moving forward. I jumped over to the private sector because, frankly, I am more excited by the opportunity to really drive the work. At the end of every day, you know you’ve made a difference for people—and our customers tell us that.” Rogers says that home performance is at the nexus of energy-efficiency advocates, environmentalists, policy makers, manufacturers, and contractors. “This makes sense on so many levels. The market is beginning to recognize the potential and invest accordingly. And for the circles in government that make policy decisions, it’s much easier to create a viable program if you have a growing infrastructure to deliver it to.”
Why HVAC Contractors Are Reluctant
Having witnessed the evolution of home energy from the start, Rogers has some insight as to why so many HVAC contractors have been reluctant to jump on the home performance bandwagon, especially when it would seem to make so much business sense.
“Back 10 or 12 years ago, we had to struggle just to get the attention of any residential contractor, period,” says Rogers. “There’s a tremendous amount of inertia. For the most part, residential contractors tend to be family-owned businesses. So whatever they do goes right back to them and their families. They are very risk averse and can’t afford to just jump into every new idea that comes along. Some of the leaders in this new concept either had a little more luxury or were, in fact, risk takers.”
“Home performance is not magic,” Rogers adds. “You do have to have your business fundamentals in place to move into this new area or you won’t succeed.”
But there is another critical reason why HVAC contractors have held back—one that does not necessarily mean that they are negatively closed minded. “There has been a history of various state agencies and utilities offering incentives to improve home performance, which have turned out to be too risky and uncertain,” Rogers says. “These programs have had the tendency to come and go. A contractor would stake his well-being on these programs, and then the provider would come along and pull the rug out. The contractor would, in good faith, go to the time and expense of getting his folks trained and certified under program A, and then have the provider say, ‘Well, we’ve changed our mind. We’re no longer doing program A, but here’s our new program B. This is what you have to do to qualify for program B.’ That’s not a real compelling argument to make to a contractor who’s just seen that his entire investment has been thrown away, while he’s been burdened by a tremendous amount of paperwork.”
Rogers is quick to point out that programs can be great if they’re executed properly. “But no contractor in his right mind should jump into home performance simply because of a program. Nor should he shy away from it because it is offered in a program. In fact, I’ve had several leading HVAC contractors in this area tell me that if the programs they are participating in went away tomorrow, they would still be doing home performance.” Rogers also asks, “If you’ve gone over all the hurdles, why not leverage your business? If you find out that meeting your customers’ needs for comfort, IAQ, or energy performance doesn’t require a furnace, why not have the additional tools at hand to deliver what will make your customer happy? If your only tool is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.”
Rogers also adds that “once you’ve cleared the hurdles of licensing, training, and technical challenges, moving in the whole-home direction makes tons of sense, because you have the most important sales ingredient already in your favor. We have some 120 million single and multifamily homes in this country. And all of the utilities, state, and federal agencies have failed to be invited into a single one. But HVAC contractors are invited into an estimated 60,000 to 100,000 homes every single day. The contractor is already there, so he or she can inspect the home and educate the homeowner on much more comprehensive ways to improve the efficiency of their home. He or she can guarantee results, then take control of the entire project to make the house better, as well as increase revenues and profitability margins.
“It’s very interesting that over the past few years, with the sagging economy, conventional HVAC contractors have really struggled. Yet while they are sucking wind, just struggling to stay alive, the contractors who have really embraced home performance are growing. The typical mainstream contractor is scratching his head asking why his competitor has 20 trucks on the road while his are sitting in the parking lot. Now that the leaders in the industry are moving in the right direction, I don’t think it will be that long before the mass of contractors follow,” Rogers says.
GreenHomes America, based in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, is a part of ABM that’s dedicated exclusively to helping HVAC contractors make the transition to home performance, says area manager Rayji Powers. “We have a network of contractors across the United States with revenues ranging from an annual $2 million to $20 million. We provide not just the home performance aspect as an add-on, but rather a full business system, and help them build it as a performance culture. We help them expand their business, and provide everything from installation through the administration process to the generation of energy savings, with all of the qualitative and technical modeling, plus full ongoing support.”
Powers also says that GreenHomes works closely with, and serves on the board of, BPI, and has a similar cooperative relationship with ACCA.
Ken Justo, co-owner and CEO of ASI Hastings Heating, Air Conditioning & Solar in San Diego, California, has high praise for GreenHomes. “When you become BPI certified, that lays the foundation, but it’s just the ticket to the game. It doesn’t really prepare you to do practical work in the field. Here’s where GreenHomes America comes in. The company has been doing it for over 20 years, and has done over 15,000 homes. So its training is based on real-life experiences. We have over 2,000 hours of GreenHomes training.”
Justo says it took a while; some starts and stops occurred on a steep learning curve, before his company got the proper training and traction took hold. He notes that a lot of contractors have to go through a similar process.
“We’ve been doing this for about 18 months, but for the first 6 months we had no quality control plan,” Justo says. “We had to make nine visits to one home to get the project approved. This is not good for California, where there are a lot of dual family breadwinners, making it necessary for one of them to be at home those nine times. We knew we had to streamline the process, to make it user-friendly.” But this ongoing process of quality improvement can be difficult and expensive. “Since we are in a private industry, we don’t have someone else doing research and development for us. So we have to do it ourselves to iron out the wrinkles, and this is costly.”
Justo also sees problems with the energy savings incentives offered by utility companies and others. “In California, 12¢ is taken out of every home’s energy bill for those incentives,” he explains. “The person billed doesn’t even know what this is for, but it adds up to a considerable sum, which the utilities then offer to homeowners to become more energy efficient. The problem is that many of the implementers and inspection agents who receive the bid to work on behalf of the utilities and get to the homeowners are not very well trained. This makes it awkward for the homeowner and difficult for the contractor. And this was a key reason why we had to go back to that one home nine times. They say, here are the guidelines for incentives and customer performance, so then we do our job reporting, and they say it’s right. But they’ve changed the rules in midstream, and say, do it over. It’s very costly.”
The good news, however, is that both federal and state government agencies are improving. “They are learning, and are at least reaching out and interacting with the contractor, listening to what he has to say. Both the federal and state governments are very sincere in fashioning programs that work. The attitude is great in this state. The goal is to reduce greenhouse emission levels to what they were in 1990 by 2020,” Justo says.
“But the best part,” he says, is people’s reactions when we deliver on our three main goals of air quality, comfort, and energy savings. Especially when they see the health results, they are ecstatic. The American Lung Association says the worst air pollution problems often occur in people’s own homes. So when homeowners tell you they or their children no longer have asthma or are off medications, you know that you are really changing lives.”
Brad Bartholomew, president of Bartholomew Heating & Cooling, Kalamazoo, Michigan, reports that his family-owned business was started in 1955, with the transition from HVAC into home performance starting in about 2003. “It’s been a constant evolution, one that’s continuing to evolve,” he says. “With an existing company, it’s like a ship, difficult to change course. The bigger the company, the more difficult.”
Bartholomew says that for his midsized 15-employee company, “there were a lot of cultural issues. We had to have a buy-in all across the company, from the person who answers the phone to the field technicians to the sales staff. We had to both encourage the change in attitude and enforce it. But once people really understood the concept, it made ultimate good sense, and the changes are now implemented.”
One issue that comes to the fore, Bartholomew continues, “is that a new piece of HVAC equipment can mean more profit than an energy savings measure, which might come down to common sense. This was not a big issue with us. In some companies there is the pressure to make the sale, but even before, we’d try to sell the customer only what he needs. If he might have needed a new furnace in two or three years, we would have told him that, and not tried to push for the sale right away. We had a much more limited toolbox then. But it is true that putting in HVAC equipment or new windows is down on the list of things that need to be done.”
Nevertheless, the incorporation of energy savings into the business has helped the bottom line. “Home performance has really eliminated the peaks and valleys. Up here it’s cold in the winter and hot in the summer, with moderate spring and fall. We’ve ended seasonal slowdowns, and haven’t laid off anybody in nine or ten years. Once you get known as a problem solver, you find it’s a huge business builder.”
Moreover, between the old and new there’s been no real change in philosophy. “We’ve always believed that getting a customer is more important than making a sale, that if you do the right thing it somehow works out,” Bartholomew says. “As my grandfather used to say, ‘It’s never wrong to do the right thing.’”
The Future and the Need for Education
Jerry Unruh, president of ABC Cooling & Heating in Fresno, California, says, “We’ve been HVAC contractors for 50 years. This is what we do. A few years ago I started reading in the trade magazines about fixing the envelope of the home, and the company has grown from there. First the boxes, then the ductwork, then home energy. There’s still a lot of education that needs to be done with contractors. The more I travel and the more I speak, the more I hear contractors say, ‘Wow, this really makes sense. But we’ll wait until tomorrow.’ But things have changed. Tomorrow is today, and we all have to go green.” (For a complete list of upsides and downsides to transitioning into home performance, see Table 1.)
Unruh reaffirms the similar points made by those quoted above, but he adds a couple of telling details. The first is that “there are 33,000 BPI-certified people, but only 10% of them are doing any work in this area. So the industry still has a lot of maturing to do.”
The second fact that Unruh mentions is that someone simply going into homes to do free audits doesn’t necessarily translate into home improvements. “We found in one city, the residents were provided with 3,000 free audits, and not one took advantage of any of the incentives or made any energy improvements.” In other words, homeowners don’t have a tendency to do it themselves. And this is the opportunity for the contractor.
Contractors can finance a package that bundles the whole thing together, and then they become the one person the homeowner can hold responsible. “What we do when we audit takes about three hours to do in a full assessment. We then are able to provide a priority list, telling the homeowner just what he needs to do to save so much, and let him proceed in terms of his own inclinations and budget. Once he’s sold on the concept of the holistic home, he’s likely to want to make his home one,” Unruh says.
To review DOE’s Buildings Energy Data Book, visit www.buildingsdatabook.eren.doe.gov.
To learn more about Carrier’s Energy Experts program, go to http://myhomeenergyexperts.com.
To leave the final word to ABM’s Mike Rogers: “In looking at regional electrical generation capacities, the needs, over the next five years, will be huge. There are not enough facilities, so more will have to be built, and no one wants them in their backyard. To tap into the real potential to meet this need, experts agree efficiency has to be a serious part of the mix. But we have to look beyond changing lightbulbs to probing much deeper to improve every home. We’re about to enter the perfect storm, and have no good option but to accelerate the growth of home performance.”
Enter your comments in the box below:
(Please note that all comments are subject to review prior to posting.)
While we will do our best to monitor all comments and blog posts for accuracy and relevancy, Home Energy is not responsible for content posted by our readers or third parties. Home Energy reserves the right to edit or remove comments or blog posts that do not meet our community guidelines.