Converging Trends

Posted by Rick Barnett on May 24, 2016
Converging Trends Rigid insulation on a new building. The lower half of the home shows what an existing house being optimized would look like, prior to re-installing the siding. (Owens Corning)

Environmental Leader recently described legal challenges faced by a business coalition supporting the “Clean Power Plan.” Aside from the Supreme Court’s intervention, the coalition “is fighting more than 20 energy companies, other businesses and industry organizations, and 27 states that filed lawsuits to overturn the EPA rules.”

US Chamber of Commerce President Tom Donohue recently commented about the 166 state and local Chamber affiliates fighting the Clean Power Plan: the groups are "natural allies in the fight because the states will be on the hook for these radical, federally mandated reductions.”

While some utilities disregard the controversy and continue working toward Power Plan goals, reduced emissions resulting from the Plan are difficult to predict.    

Other business organizations are promoting market-based emission reduction.  For example, The American Sustainable Business Council has a campaign promoting a carbon tax as a “market” solution. Although 81 of the largest US companies signed President Obama's “American Business Climate Pledge,” Republicans called Obama’s proposed carbon tax "dead on arrival". The potential for emission reduction from a carbon tax is also difficult to predict.

And despite remarkable global growth, renewables supply only 1.1% of the world’s energy, compared to 60.4% by coal and oil, according to the International Energy Agency (pages 6 and 28). 

With obstacles filling the clean energy landscape, business efforts to create a low-carbon future need to look more closely at the biggest piece of the residential energy pie.  DOE’s 2011 Buildings Energy Data Book indicates that  “space heating and cooling – which combined account for 54% of site energy consumption and 43% of primary energy consumption –drive residential energy demand (page 62).”   

Despite this glaring target, US efficiency programs have done little to curb space conditioning energy, or improve the thermal performance of our country’s 130 million homes.  And no improvement is expected in the near future, according to a recent American Council for an Energy Efficiency Economy publication, “New Horizons for Energy Efficiency:  Major Opportunities to Reach Higher Electricity Savings by 2030”.  They credit whole-building retrofits with only 1% of emerging efficiency investments.  The ACEEE report suggests that space conditioning will remain the largest piece of homeowner energy expense.  

Several trends have converged to create an opportunity for utilities to cut space conditioning energy by financing high performance retrofits, for metropolitan or small town homeowners:

  • Utilities are responding to emission constraints and state utility commissions with growing demand-side investment.
  • Existing efficiency programs are not taking steps to reduce the largest portion of residential energy demand, space conditioning.
  • Several home performance scoring systems have been developed, including this from DOE.
  • The insulation industry has created high performance thermal systems.
  • Utilities are pursuing new opportunities to improve service and retain customers.
  • RESNET has connected performance scoring to the energy code, and introduced real estate and appraisal professionals to the value of high performance.
  • Utilities are facing disruptive challenges including renewables, customer retention, power plant closure, and peak overload.
  • Utility-financed residential solar exists at a limited pilot scale, but faces many challenges including unresolved maintenance and liability issues.

These trends elevate the feasibility of a utility-scale program to optimize the thermal performance of customer homes. Homeowners would enjoy greater comfort without new expense, and use the least amount of space conditioning energy. On-bill financing for the retrofit results in a long term customer for the utility. And the value of measured demand reduction would allow utilities to offer optimized retrofits at no new cost to the current or future homeowner. 

Without tax dollars or government agencies, the utility, construction and insulation industries could collaborate to seal our leaky homes. An example of similar private sector conservation can be found in 1980’s recycling. The waste hauling industry adjusted a historical disinterest in conservation and began offering household recycling as a new service for customers.  Without public financing, private industry was able to maintain flow control, create jobs and conserve resources.

As an expanded utility service to residential customers, thermal optimization would give local economies a much-needed jolt. The task may seem large, but the value of greater resilience and fewer emissions would increase over the life of an optimized home.        


Rick BarnettRick Barnett has a B.A. in psychology and an Interdisciplinary Masters in Environmental Management. Before becoming a builder, Rick was involved with recycling, including the initiation of the first campus-wide recycling program in the US, at Oregon State University in 1975.

Rick started Green Builder in 1996, and initiated several public sector green building programs over the next 10 years. As a general contractor, his experience included several rigid-wrapped high performance projects. His current focus is promoting high performance homes. 

Add a new blog comment!

Enter your comments in the box below:

(Please note that all blog entries and comments are subject to review prior to posting.)


While we will do our best to monitor all comments and blog posts for accuracy and relevancy, Home Energy is not responsible for content posted by our readers or third parties. Home Energy reserves the right to edit or remove comments or blog posts that do not meet our community guidelines.

Recent Blogs
Converging Trends

Converging Trends

Rick Barnett

Environmental Leader recently described legal challenges faced by a business coalitionsupporting the “Clean Power Plan.” Aside from the Supreme Court’s intervention, the coalition “is fighting more than 20 energy companies, other businesses and industry organizations, and 27 states that filed lawsuits to overturn the EPA rules.” [continue reading]

11 Flavors of Sustainable Housing

11 Flavors of Sustainable Housing

Shawna Henderson

Keeping track of what's going on in the world of low-impact, sustainable housing is, and was, a challenge. [continue reading]

EnergyLogic and The Energy Conservatory Put

EnergyLogic and The Energy Conservatory Put "Game of Homes" into Play

Linda Lidov

EnergyLogic welcomes The Energy Conservatory (TEC) as its cornerstone partner in the introduction of Game of Homes, EnergyLogic’s new, free gamification-based training platform for home performance professionals. As the first Game of Homes sponsor, TEC enjoys early marketing rights to pioneer players – exposing them to TEC’s specialized tools for creating more efficient, affordable and healthy buildings. In playing the game, home energy professionals gain valuable continuing education units (CEUs). [continue reading]

Millennials Trust the Smart Home Revolution, but For How Long?

Millennials Trust the Smart Home Revolution, but For How Long?

Andy Heikkila

Brands and products that aren’t trusted by Millennials are doomed to fail, with Gen Y making up more and more of the general market-base than ever before. Fortunately for the green and the smart home movement, Millennials currently do trust and want more smart home technology in their lives—but for how long? With looming threats on cybersecurity on the horizon, Millennial trust in the smart home movement may just have been ... [continue reading]

Tankless Water Heaters: Energy Efficiency, On Demand

Tankless Water Heaters: Energy Efficiency, On Demand

Tom Kelly

Homeowners are growing increasingly conscious of their carbon footprint and taking steps to go green, both by retrofitting existing structures or by installing more energy-efficient appliances and fixtures. Something homeowners might not be thinking about, however, is how much their water heater affects their total energy use – in fact, most people don’t think about their water heater at all; it gets installed in a closet and forgotten about as long as it&... [continue reading]

greeNEWit Honored by EPA as 2016 Energy Star Contractor of the Year

greeNEWit Honored by EPA as 2016 Energy Star Contractor of the Year

Sarah Frye

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has recognized greeNEWit with a 2016 ENERGY STAR Contractor of the Year Award for its outstanding efforts to increase the adoption of energy-efficient products in homes. greeNEWit’s accomplishments will be recognized in Washington, D.C. on April 13, 2016. [continue reading]

NESEA Hudson Valley Group May 2016 Monastery Retrofit Workshop

NESEA Hudson Valley Group May 2016 Monastery Retrofit Workshop

Luis Hernandez

NESEA Hudson Valley Group welcomes you to ourspring 2016 Monastery Workshop Series. The main purpose of this project is to produce a deep, detailed Home Performance Energy Audit in order to establish a work scope for energy measures that includes health and safety as well. We will evaluate all possible energy saving targets, and prepare the beautiful Holy Cross Monastery for appropriate sustainable energy solutions. [continue reading]

Our Relationship Status with Sustainability: It's Complicated

Our Relationship Status with Sustainability: It's Complicated

Shawna Henderson

I was going to write today about the range of energy efficient and sustainable housing standards and programs that are offered by organizations. But I got sidetracked by an article by Allison Bailes on his Energy Vanguard blog. [continue reading]

Sewage Heat Recovery

Sewage Heat Recovery

Lynn Mueller

Environmental awareness is spreading across countries like a slow, yet steady, fire. Enterprises that focus on energy saving schemes are constantly on the lookout for fresh ideas. Nearly every second day, a new project is charted out in some part of the world. Some of them fail due to lack of funding, while others collapse because of their irrational basis. Only once in a while, an idea that is conceived actually makes it into the ... [continue reading]

To Certify or Not to Certify? A Good Question

To Certify or Not to Certify? A Good Question

Rob Nicely

Our rationale of following the path of Passive House, LEED, Zero Net Energy, Living Building Challenge or other specific set of guidelines is not to achieve a certification to have in our portfolio. These programs provide standards that achieve a better quality home with high energy efficiency, interior spaces that are comfortable, have healthy air quality and are quiet, yield a durable home that has a lower carbon footprint and is kinder to the planet, ... [continue reading]

Earn BPI CEU credits
Home Performance with EnergyStar

Harness the power of

Get the Home Energy